I’m afraid my first foray into the world of Netbooks is over. After spending a day working with my new Dell Mini 9 Netbook, I’ve decided to return it. It’s a really nice machine, but it had some major deficienices that were a deal breaker for me. So here are my comments regarding the Mini 9:
Positive Attributes - The Dell Mini 9 is a well constructed mini-laptop with the fit-n-finish that I expected from Dell. It has a nice clear, crisp screen and ran silently (no fans or whirling hard drive). The battery life was great, and the integrated WiFi connected to my home network effortlessly. I also installed Windows 7 Beta (slimmed down) on the 16 GB SSD drive and it ran surprisingly well with just 1 GB of RAM memory. The Intel Atom CPU seemed to do just fine in running the different applications I tested (FireFox, OpenOffice, XAMPP Server, Thunderbird Email Client, etc).
Negative Attributes – There were two big issues that I could not overcome: The first, was the small keyboard size and misplacement of critical keys. I’m a touch typist (albeit, not the fastest), and the small keyboard just felt too cramped for me to type emails and blog entries. In addition, certain keys such as the single and double quote characters as well as the hyphen key were not located in the same place as a standard keyboard. Also, the period key was significantly smaller than the other letter keys which caused me to accidentally press one of its adjacent keys. For the hunt-n-peck two finger typist this wouldn’t be such a problem, but for a touch typist such as I it is a big problem.
The second big issue is the 1024×600 screen resolution, specifically the 600 pixel vertical height. For most of the web pages I visited, I immediately needed to scroll vertically to read the actual content on the page (since most pages have big headers or banners at the top of their pages). It was just too frustrating to have to scroll vertically immediately on every page I visited. I should have know this by examining the screen resolution specs for the Dell Mini 9 before purchasing it, however, you really don’t feel the effects until you actually experience it yourself with real-life use.
So because of these to big issues, I’m returning my Dell Mini 9 to Costco for a full refund (fortunately, Costco offers a 90-day return on laptops, no questions asked).
So then I thought, “What are my requirements for a suitable Netbook that would meet my needs?” So here’s what I came up with:
- Small, lightweight, and portable
- Long battery life (3-4 hours) on a single charge
- High resolution screen (1024×800 pixels minimum)
- Large keyboard with standard key placement (92% standard size?)
- Solid State Disk (SSD) drive for reliability and silent operation
- CPU that is fast enough to run Windows XP/Vista/7 (Intel Atom processor?)
- Memory upgradable to 2 GB RAM
- SDHC card slot for storing files (since SSD drive may be limited in size)
- Integrated WiFi (with good range)
- USB ports (3 minimum)
- VGA video output (standard on nearly all laptops)
- Headphone jack
- Network Port
Now, the actual size of the Netbook would be determined by a usable keyboard size, which seems to fall in the 10″ screen range. Additionally, since my eyesight is still pretty good for reading small print, I could go with a high resolution screen (1280×1024 or higher if available) to compensate for the small screen size.
With a current review of available Netbooks on the market, it seems that not one of them will meet my wish list. There are some that seem to satisfy my keyboard requirement (Hp Mini 1000, Dell Mini 10/12), but not enough of my other requirements. Also, there’s a price consideration, as to satisfy my wish list the cost of a Netbook could rise to the level of a traditional laptop, which in my case would negate the justification for purchasing it.
So for now, I’m back to using my Dell Latitude D610 (14″ 1400×1050 screen) which isn’t the most portable and has a 1-hour battery life, but I’ll keep my eye out for the next incarnation of the Netbook machines.